Why it is Better to Avoid Optimising Your Character

In tabletop roleplaying games, players can create unique characters with special abilities, skills, and characteristics. However, a new trend of mathematical optimisation in character creation has caused concern among some players and Game Masters (GMs). This approach is taken by players who focus on maximising their characters' abilities and power while sacrificing other important aspects of the game, such as roleplaying, group dynamics, storytelling, and fun.

While creating a powerful character that excels in combat may be tempting, this approach can be detrimental to the game experience. Characters optimised mathematically often lack interesting backstories, personalities, or flaws, and these elements are crucial in creating a well-rounded character that is engaging and fun to play. With them, the character may be more interesting to interact with other characters, making the game more enjoyable for everyone involved.

Furthermore, this approach to character creation can also disrupt the group dynamic. In a roleplaying game, a group often consists of different characters with different abilities and strengths that complement each other. Optimising a single character to be the best at everything may not benefit the group and lead to frustration and dissatisfaction among other players.

Another vital aspect of roleplaying games is storytelling. A character optimised mathematically often needs more exciting story arcs or character flaws, making the game less engaging for both the players and the GM. Characters with compelling backstories, personalities, and abilities make the game more enjoyable and immersive for everyone involved.

In addition to its impact on the game experience, this approach also implies a moral concern. Character optimisation becomes a competition between players, and the characters are no longer being used as a tool to tell a collective story but rather to gain an advantage over others and showcase their own cleverness. This attitude can create a negative atmosphere that may spoil the fun for everyone.

While mathematical optimisation can create powerful characters in tabletop RPGs, it should not be the only or primary consideration when creating a character for the game. Players should focus on creating well-rounded characters with interesting backstories, personalities, and abilities that fit well with the story and setting of the game. This approach will make the game more enjoyable for you, the other players, and the GM. And ultimately, it will provide a more immersive and engaging storytelling experience for everyone involved.